Everyday Life

Why Are Keyboards Laid Out QWERTY?

By BodaWiki EditorialPublished 5 min read

In short

QWERTY comes from the Sholes & Glidden typewriter, which Remington began selling in 1874.[2][3] A popular story says the keys were arranged to slow typists and stop jams, but researchers Koichi and Motoko Yasuoka argue the layout grew out of telegraph work and efforts to avoid old patents.[5][3] By their account, it was the industry's de facto standard by 1898.[3]

A Sholes & Glidden typewriter made by E. Remington & Sons in the 1870s, on display in a museum: a black iron machine with a green front panel and painted flowers, a cylindrical platen on top and four rows of round white keys. The top letter row begins Q, W, E, R, T, Y, while the bottom row reads Z, C, X rather than today's Z, X, C.
Photo: Daderot, 2013. CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Key facts

Sholes, Glidden & Soulé typewriter patent
US 79,265, granted 23 June 1868[1][2]
Remington manufacturing contract
1 March 1873[3]
Sholes & Glidden Type-Writer on sale
1874[2][3]
Today's QWERTY arrangement
Remington Standard No. 2, sold by Wyckoff, Seamans & Benedict (set up August 1882): M moved next to N, C and X swapped (Yasuoka & Yasuoka)[3]
De facto industry standard
By June 1898 (Yasuoka & Yasuoka)[3]
Dvorak keyboard patent
Filed 21 May 1932, granted 12 May 1936[6][7]

Where did the QWERTY layout come from?

The layout began on a writing machine developed in Milwaukee by Christopher Latham Sholes with Carlos Glidden and Samuel Soulé.[2] Their US patent 79,265, an "improvement in type-writing machines", was granted on 23 June 1868.[1][2] According to researchers Koichi and Motoko Yasuoka, the machine shipped to its first customer, a Chicago telegraph college, in November 1868 had 28 piano-like keys in alphabetical order: A to N left to right, then O to Z right to left.[3]

The arrangement then changed many times. The Yasuokas link several changes to telegraph businessmen who promised to buy machines; S, they suggest, ended up between Z and E because American Morse code for Z was easily confused with the letter pair SE.[3] On 1 March 1873 Sholes's business associate James Densmore signed a manufacturing contract with the arms maker E. Remington & Sons, and the Sholes & Glidden Type-Writer went on sale in 1874.[3][4][2] After further changes made with Remington's mechanics, the Yasuokas write, Sholes patented the keyboard arrangement.[3] The patent they cite, US 207,559, was granted to Sholes on 27 August 1878 and includes a drawing of the keyboard.[3][8]

Today's exact layout came later. In August 1882 Remington agreed to sell its typewriters exclusively through a new company, Wyckoff, Seamans & Benedict.[3] According to the Yasuokas, that company's Remington Standard Type-Writer No. 2 was slightly redesigned to get around patents held by the Type Writer Company: M moved next to N and C swapped with X, giving the QWERTY arrangement still in use.[3]

Was QWERTY designed to slow typists down?

A widely repeated story says so. Economists Stan Liebowitz and Stephen Margolis note the common claim that the layout was meant to slow typing and so prevent jams.[5] MIT's Lemelson program says the type bars tended to jam, Densmore suggested separating keys for letters often typed together, and so the keyboard was "invented to slow down typing."[2] In 1985 the economic historian Paul David described Sholes rearranging the alphabetical keys by trial and error to reduce typebar clashes.[4][5]

The Yasuokas call the slow-down story false.[3] The machine's early users, they argue, were telegraph operators taking down Morse code, who had to keep pace with the sender, so slowing them down would have made no sense.[3] Examining Sholes & Glidden machines held in museums, they found that the ring of type bars did not match the keyboard in any systematic way, and that E and R, the second most common letter pair in their table, sat on neighbouring bars.[3] They also reject David's account that, once R took the place of the period key, all the letters of TYPE WRITER sat on one row for salesmen to tap out.[4][3] They note that the brand name had already been set as "Sholes & Glidden Type-Writer" before that change, and that the machine was demonstrated by taking down telegraph messages or dictation.[3] In their view there was no consistent plan: the layout shifted first for telegraph work, then as a compromise between inventors and manufacturer, and finally to avoid old patents.[3]

Is the Dvorak keyboard faster?

August Dvorak, an education professor at the University of Washington, and his brother-in-law William Dealey applied for a patent on a new keyboard on 21 May 1932; it was granted on 12 May 1936.[6][7] Their layout put the vowels together in one left-hand row, grouped common consonant pairs close together and placed most of the typing on the home row.[7] According to HistoryLink, typists using it set 26 international records between 1933 and 1941.[7] In 1944 the US Navy retrained 14 clerks on it; according to Dvorak, the Navy estimated that the training cost was recovered within 10 days.[7]

Liebowitz and Margolis challenged that evidence in "The Fable of the Keys" (Journal of Law and Economics, 1990), which they summarised in Reason magazine in 1996.[5] They report, citing Earle Strong of Pennsylvania State University, that Dvorak himself ran the 1944 Navy test.[5] They rely instead on Strong's mid-1950s study for the General Services Administration, in which retrained typists needed well over 25 days of four-hour sessions to regain their old QWERTY speed and then improved more slowly than QWERTY typists given extra training.[5] They also quote two IBM researchers who found no alternative with a "realistically significant advantage" over QWERTY for general typing.[5]

HistoryLink records that the government decided against switching, saying the gains were smaller and retraining longer than claimed; Dvorak suspected pressure from typewriter makers, and one supporter called the conclusions "shockingly biased".[7] It adds that later studies mostly found modest efficiency gains for Dvorak over QWERTY.[7]

Why did QWERTY become the standard?

The Yasuokas point to business consolidation: in 1893 the Union Typewriter Company was formed as a trust over five leading makers, including Remington, and once all five used QWERTY it had become the de facto standard by June 1898.[3] Teletype machines adopted QWERTY in the 1910s and served as computer terminals in the United States, Britain and Japan from the 1940s to the 1970s, which, they say, is why computer keyboards there still use it.[3]

Paul David stresses typists' skills. Touch typing arrived in the late 1880s and was built around Remington's QWERTY keyboard; in his account, the need for machines to match what typists had memorised, economies of scale and the cost of retraining then "locked in" the layout.[4] Other makers could cheaply switch their machines to QWERTY to suit trained typists, but the typists could not easily switch.[4] David concluded that the industry had standardised too early "on the wrong system".[4]

Liebowitz and Margolis reject the idea that QWERTY won by accident. Rivals such as Hammond and Blickensderfer offered their own layouts and typing contests were common, yet these companies ended up making QWERTY keyboards too.[5] In 1996 they noted that computer keyboards could be switched to Dvorak at almost no cost apart from retraining, yet few users had done so; in their view, no rival layout has offered enough advantage to justify a change.[5]

Frequently asked questions

Who invented the QWERTY keyboard?

The layout grew out of the typewriter that Christopher Latham Sholes developed in Milwaukee with Carlos Glidden and Samuel Soulé.[2] According to Koichi and Motoko Yasuoka, it changed many times with input from telegraph businessmen and Remington's mechanics, and reached today's form on a model sold by Wyckoff, Seamans & Benedict, a company set up in 1882.[3]

Was QWERTY made to stop typewriters jamming?

Some accounts say so: MIT's Lemelson program says keys were split up because the type bars jammed, and Paul David described Sholes reducing typebar clashes by trial and error.[2][4] Koichi and Motoko Yasuoka dispute this, noting that E and R, the second most common letter pair in their table, sat on neighbouring type bars.[3]

Is the Dvorak keyboard faster than QWERTY?

The evidence is disputed. Dvorak's supporters point to typing records and a 1944 Navy test, while Liebowitz and Margolis argue that Dvorak himself ran that test and cite a 1950s government study whose author concluded that retraining on Dvorak would never pay for itself.[7][5] HistoryLink says later studies mostly found modest efficiency gains for Dvorak.[7]

Why do computers still use QWERTY?

According to Koichi and Motoko Yasuoka, Teletype machines adopted QWERTY in the 1910s and were later used as computer terminals, so computer keyboards kept the layout.[3] Paul David argues that typists' training locked the layout in, while Liebowitz and Margolis say no alternative has offered enough advantage to justify a change.[4][5]

Sources

  1. [1]US Patent 79,265: Improvement in type-writing machines (1868) · Google Patents (USPTO record) · accessed October 8, 2026
  2. [2]Christopher Sholes: The Typewriter · Lemelson-MIT Program, Massachusetts Institute of Technology · accessed October 8, 2026
  3. [3]On the Prehistory of QWERTY (ZINBUN, No. 42) · Koichi Yasuoka and Motoko Yasuoka, Kyoto University Research Information Repository · accessed October 8, 2026
  4. [4]Clio and the Economics of QWERTY (American Economic Review, Vol. 75, No. 2, May 1985; copy hosted by UC Santa Barbara) · Paul A. David, American Economic Review · accessed October 8, 2026
  5. [5]Typing Errors (by S. J. Liebowitz and Stephen E. Margolis, Reason, June 1996) · Reason · accessed October 8, 2026
  6. [6]US Patent 2,040,248: Typewriter keyboard (1936) · Google Patents (USPTO record) · accessed October 8, 2026
  7. [7]Dvorak, August (1894-1975) (HistoryLink.org Essay 20997, by Lane Morgan, posted 19 March 2020) · HistoryLink.org · accessed October 8, 2026
  8. [8]US Patent 207,559: Improvement in type-writing machines (1878) · Google Patents (USPTO record) · accessed October 8, 2026
Cite this article
APA
BodaWiki Editorial. (2026, October 9). Why Are Keyboards Laid Out QWERTY? BodaWiki. https://bodawiki.com/wiki/why-are-keyboards-qwerty
MLA
“Why Are Keyboards Laid Out QWERTY?” BodaWiki, 9 Oct. 2026, bodawiki.com/wiki/why-are-keyboards-qwerty.
Chicago
BodaWiki Editorial. “Why Are Keyboards Laid Out QWERTY?” BodaWiki. October 9, 2026. https://bodawiki.com/wiki/why-are-keyboards-qwerty.
  • keyboards
  • typewriters
  • qwerty
  • dvorak
  • history of technology